• 0 Posts
  • 11 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: September 17th, 2025

help-circle

  • I’d settled to a similar conclusion for a while, but I could not ignore how we seem to be approaching our planet’s thermodynamic limits. We have disrupted the natural flow and cycles of energy to the point of, I think, a global climate refugee crisis in my lifetime. Its arguably already begun.

    We’ve “simply” burned too much, and too fast, low entropy fuel and our Sun-Earth system can only expel so much thermal energy, and increasingly less so as greenhouse gases continue to accumulate and ice caps melt. We’re pressure cooking ourselves.



  • shakiiin@lemmygrad.mltoGenZedong@lemmygrad.ml•This image was made with AI
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    arrow-down
    4
    ·
    edit-2
    25 days ago

    Yes, they were in the strict sense. the luddites were trying to preserve a pre-industrial way of life. I didn’t mean to use it as a slur. They were understandably and justifiably bitter at their jobs being replaced by dead labor and wages being cut, at becoming more and more the instruments of the machine. They were lacking in a methodology to contextualize their struggles within the social relations of capitalist production and only revolted against the instruments of capital.

    the luddites were not “reactionary” in the sense of siding with the ruling class, clearly.

    Idk why you are bringing up immigration here, that is clearly not the kind of reactionary tendency that is being discussed.


  • shakiiin@lemmygrad.mltoGenZedong@lemmygrad.ml•This image was made with AI
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    6
    ·
    edit-2
    26 days ago

    i had this exact same point brought against me when discussing LTV and socially necessary labor time with a liberal. yes indeed, 300 hours of shit labor is of course socially less valuable than 3 hours of skilled, quality labor. some workers learn skills faster than others, too. the value of an object of labor is determined in a social context at exchange, where the prices of objects find an equilibrium. (also, how can you so easily brush aside the thousands of hours of crystallized past labor that is needed for one to become someone with expertise? is all that time not the requirement to gain those skills, maybe except for the rare child genius?) but i am not discussing the exchange value of the AI agitprop vs human made agitprop. i am saying that the very use value of AI agitprop is hollowed out. those hours of crystallized labor are in the skilled laborer. that crystallized labor, of personal activity, is not present in an LLM prompt. that personal activity, by which humans exert our expression on the material world, has been stripped. all activity is externalized almost completely. that is the narrower point i am trying to convey. as you say, AI is a technology, capable of being used as a tool of surplus value extraction or of surplus “time injection.” yes, i am actually pro-using AI to reduce the socially necessary time it takes to do tasks no one really wants to do (within environmental and social constraints, ofc). i do not think memes and comics, as much as you may disagree, fall in that category. (also to note, is the early template based meme virality not evidence of “efficiency” in action, but still allowing for genuine creativity to flourish? to make it easier for folks with less computer skills but plenty of imagination to make art? was there ever really a need for AI here?) where is the shared human expression, the life activity, that i see in human-made memes but not in AI memes? i don’t think i can lay it out any better. bye.


  • shakiiin@lemmygrad.mltoGenZedong@lemmygrad.ml•This image was made with AI
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    9
    ·
    edit-2
    26 days ago

    fetishizing individual hard work? my friend, there is no shame in doing hard work, it is the alienation of the proletariat from the product of our labor, the division of labor and exchange that turns workers into commodities, by which yes, the worker-commodity is fetishized. AI generated marxist agitprop is just such an oxymoron i cannot ignore!

    marx’s point is that work is not merely instrumental, but how we realize ourselves as humans.

    "For labor, life activity, productive life itself, appears to man in the first place merely as a means of satisfying a need – the need to maintain physical existence. Yet the productive life is the life of the species. It is life-engendering life. The whole character of a species, its species-character, is contained in the character of its life activity; and free, conscious activity is man’s species-character. Life itself appears only as a means to life.

    …

    In creating a world of objects by his personal activity, in his work upon inorganic nature, man proves himself a conscious species-being, i.e., as a being that treats the species as his own essential being, or that treats itself as a species-being. Admittedly animals also produce. They build themselves nests, dwellings, like the bees, beavers, ants, etc. But an animal only produces what it immediately needs for itself or its young. It produces one-sidedly, whilst man produces universally. It produces only under the dominion of immediate physical need, whilst man produces even when he is free from physical need and only truly produces in freedom therefrom. An animal produces only itself, whilst man reproduces the whole of nature. An animal’s product belongs immediately to its physical body, whilst man freely confronts his product. An animal forms only in accordance with the standard and the need of the species to which it belongs, whilst man knows how to produce in accordance with the standard of every species, and knows how to apply everywhere the inherent standard to the object. Man therefore also forms objects in accordance with the laws of beauty."

    Estranged Labour, Marx, 1844

    the fact that people resonated with the post with AI influence being omitted, leads one to assume human authorship. the reader assumes the human judgement, time, and labor that was put into it. prompting a bot externalizes all of these activities onto a model. sure, the bot can produce “fine” output, but the personal activity is lacking, it is thin. art, even internet memes, is not just the output. hard work is not the problem. work that is not yours is.

    you posted the comic on c/memes.




  • Learning that something is AI, esp something rooted in creativity, takes the wind out of its sails, so to speak. Simply less impressive, lazier, a shortcut. ML/LLMs for tedious, mundane tasks like data entry or as a “better” ctrl+F? Personally, besides the environmental problems and harm to surrounding residences of data centers, I don’t have (as) much issue with the principle of that kind of usage.

    I think we have started to lose the plot of what the hell even is a meme. My understanding was that a particular template/catchphrase becomes popular, and people make unique iterations of that, sometimes making a categorically new meme out of it. The whole fun of it to me was that people were anonymously making, typically shitty but occasionally hilarious, works of genuine art. Everyone has ideas, anyone can start conceptualizing. But if the actual realization of that concept is being materially done by a clanker, I’m admiring a megacorp’s work of art, not the lazy prompter. How much credit should we give the Bible for Da Vinci’s Last Supper? Point is, I’d prefer to admire a human’s shitty piece of work, discuss/critique/improve upon that, than whatever a cold model spits out.

    Ig u could argue a comic is a kind of meme, but I doubt that is what actually pops in someone’s head when u ask them to picture a modern meme. I wouldn’t call a singular well performing post on Lemmy as a usable data point, esp to argue on the subjective validity of AI generated work. How can u account for people who decide not to engage at all with AI posts?

    Might I rec the series “sieze the memes” available on meansTV?