infuziSporg [e/em/eir]

Every place a commune to be unleashed!

Padding the comment-to-post ratios since before choppo chæt was a thing.

  • 17 Posts
  • 4.61K Comments
Joined 5 年前
cake
Cake day: 2020年10月26日

help-circle






  • That implication isn’t certain. An alternate (charitable?) reading of it is that they’re saying that a revolutionary state dominated by anarchists (or by a broad united front) would have been strong enough to never allow the monarchies to invade, and pre-empt the fascists from taking power at least in Germany.

    This begs the question, though. Historically, we don’t see united fronts being all that stable and we don’t see anarchists becoming regional geopolitical heavy hitters. If the recipe for these clearly existed in 1917, why has it not been employed since then?

    Anyway, this is why I so firmly take the stance of “history doesn’t prove very much definitively; there simply isn’t the sample size required to be scientific”. There are lots of possible outcomes from any scenario, and no one has the special knowledge to make history proceed only in their preferred way.














  • If everyone is positioned close together, and they do all their practicing in the same location where they will eventually perform, and they are very well used to each other, and the piece/movement both starts out and ends with just one instrument or voice, and the piece is continuous without any pauses longer than one bar, and there are no fermatas or accelerandos or removedandos, then maybe you can go without a conductor.

    Every time you need to start, stop, speed up, slow down, sometimes time change, sometimes volume change, and sometimes for solos, there is a need for coordination.