Wertheimer [any]

  • 178 Posts
  • 1.84K Comments
Joined 5 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 27th, 2020

help-circle




  • Is this the first time you’ve tried to read a magazine article? Are you not familiar with the genre? You’re making a category error here, like getting angry at a bagel for not tasting like a doughnut. The purpose is not “first and foremost” to provide information in a reverse-pyramid format. In this case it’s to provide pathos and to instill in the reader the realization that “Oh, shit, this could easily happen to me or someone I care about.” John McPhee’s articles - also very long! I guess no one has ever read him! Certainly not anyone normal! - provide a structural model. McPhee often writes about geology or geography or some such, but in the context of an experience. He’ll go on a rafting journey on the Colorado River and will use dialogue with his guide to provide some information, and then zoom out to give a big (big, big) picture account of the geology of the Grand Canyon.

    It’s the same thing in Stillman’s articles on the prison system (and other New Yorker articles, like this one about the execution of Cameron Todd Willingham, which has stuck with me for 16 years), and Mary Casey’s family probably saw one of Stillman’s articles about asset forfeiture or felony murder and decided that she could be the one to tell their mother’s story. Is it liberal Pulitzer bait? Sure. But until leftists get New Yorker money we’re going to rely not only on the stats but also the narratives in these pieces. Sometimes taking a systemic injustice and giving it a particular human face is what connects with people, the way Savita Halappanavar’s story was what led to the legalization of abortion in Ireland.