Russian living in Italy.

  • 4 Posts
  • 15 Comments
Joined 7 months ago
cake
Cake day: December 1st, 2025

help-circle



  • That’s what I initially thought, but then he defends Berlinguer as a true communist, which doesn’t sound like being an ultra, more like being a social democrat… He also does talk about some vague “authoritarianism” when talking about Stalin, he just gets over it quickly.

    I just watched that video in particular, and his thesis is this: When the USSR collapsed, it was the party members and KGB agents who were the first to sell everything and become the oligarchs. (Wtf! The so-called “stalinists” were the ones who fought the most against liberalization!) He cites Trotsky’s critique of Stalin of being state capitalism and not giving the means of production to the workers, which apparently it’s what Marx wanted since the get-go (Ignoring the whole DotP and the transitional socialist state). He also does some Gorbachev “apologia”, about how he just improved civil liberties and apparently fought to save the USSR from Yeltsin, and that the USSR collapse brough both good and bad things (Which I feel I need to ask: What good things did it bring to the marxist movement? He doesn’t say any…). He also throws some shade on “stalinists”, saying things like most of them don’t know it was Yeltsin to destroy the USSR, and other stuff like that. So yeah Gorbachev and Berlinguer are communists but not Stalin.

    Very sloppy work to be honest. I also noticed that the description has no sources, which he usually puts, so I’m stamping a big:

    on the whole video.