Leon_Grotsky [comrade/them]

Resident Orkonomist, Advisor to Da Kommitte, and Hobbyist Teef Collector
Ask me 'bout Permanent WAAAAAGH!

  • 7 Posts
  • 1.04K Comments
Joined 5 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 31st, 2020

help-circle





  • More annoying nerd shit

    it’s quite clear the battle droids are more or less fully sentient.

    It’s explicitly stated that the B1 battle droids in Phantom Menace do not have independent thought, a feature omitted as a cost-cutting measure; hence the need for the massive control ships and yellow-painted commander units (which do have the capability for independent thought, so I guess as far as they go I agree with you.) The hubris behind this mistake is one of the major themes of the film.

    but they show individuality at multiple points in the film.

    This is a fine counter-argument, I 90% chalk that up to the goofy bullshit strewn around the movie (like Jarjar stepping in animal shit) and maybe 10% chalk it up to the concept in Star Wars that droids will develop sentience through accumulated experience if they don’t get regularly mind-wiped; which is another horrific concept in the convo about droid person-hood.

    I only disagree with you on the specifics of the Phantom Menace because from what I understand the average non-commander B1 unit in that movie does not have the physical hardware to perform independent thought. This is textually not the case in the subsequent prequels because the conditions change. Otherwise I wholeheartedly agree that looking at The Clone Wars (the in-universe event) through the lens of droid person-hood (and by extension, Clone person-hood) really fucks up the surface level narrative in a good way.

    At the end of the day though Star Wars is full of holes, it’s not worth arguing this in-depth about anything involved with it tbh; so your read is just as valid.











  • Here is how to fix your spoiler. Make sure to click on the View Source button next to the vote buttons to see what I did.


    Original Comment:

    I watched it a few nights back and although I thought it was well-made, well-acted, and entertaining, here are the few minor gripes I had with it: 1. The first 40 minutes were spoiled by the trailers. It felt like I was waiting for the movie to get going for a while. That’s more of a criticism of modern trailers than the movie itself though. 2. The deus ex machina ending felt anticlimactic. ::: spoiler spoiler [REDACTED] ::: Overall I enjoyed the movie and think it’s worth watching once, but I don’t think I have a desire to watch it again.


    Edited Comment:

    I watched it a few nights back and although I thought it was well-made, well-acted, and entertaining, here are the few minor gripes I had with it: 1. The first 40 minutes were spoiled by the trailers. It felt like I was waiting for the movie to get going for a while. That’s more of a criticism of modern trailers than the movie itself though. 2. The deus ex machina ending felt anticlimactic.

    spoiler

    That the council could/would just immediately band together to oust Ruffalo once they saw abuse for the first time felt very unrealistic and immediately erased the stakes of the whole movie imo

    Overall I enjoyed the movie and think it’s worth watching once, but I don’t think I have a desire to watch it again.



  • Have you ever interacted with American soldiers? Recently? The average American is used to those things.

    I am an average american and I am not used to those things. I go to work, and then I go home and cook a meal for my family.

    and the military makes more money through those contracts.

    So then why do they need my tax dollars if they have all these lucrative deals with multinational billionaire companies? Although, this is beside the point that I don’t think any part of the U.S. Military should be “making money.” JFC

    This is a simple and expected outcome of a capitalist society. If those establishments exist, we should give our soldiers the choice of having them in their lives.

    Why? I find that those establishments are neither healthy nor economical compared to a basic vegetables and rice meal.

    Do you know what our military bases actually look like? These people literally live on bases for years.

    Then I would expect the bases to have facilities that reflect this fact. That is proper logistical thinking, after all.


    If the soldiers didn’t want that food, then those places wouldn’t make money, and the military makes more money through those contracts.

    This is an entirely different problem. Why is your assumption that the base desire is for fast food and not out of a perceived more palatable alternative of a not shitty mess hall?


  • There is no official color designation for the parties; and they used to commonly be “reversed” although it varied from media outlet to outlet.

    Here's a blue Reagan button from the 1980 election.

    The colors “switching” is almost entirely a media fabrication. Different television networks trying out different colours and configurations, copying each other, chasing viewer numbers, etc. and the 2000 election is where it gets kind of standardized as what we have today.

    “My firm belief is that the turning point in red/blue states was the national map (that) USA Today ran the day after the election in 2000, in which — for whatever reason — red was Republican and blue was Democratic-”

    Keating Holland, CNN’s director of polling and election analysis from 1993 to 2014.