The Speak With Dead scene I thought was well done, and the heist and sneaking into the carriage I thought was a very D&D plan…
I fucking loved the Themberchaud scenes and Chancellor Jarnathan. Honestly the entire movie sounded like an IRL game, I think that’s why I enjoyed it so much.
“Chancellor Jarnathan enters the chamber -”
“I GRAB JARNATHAN AND JUMP OUT THE WINDOW”
"…Roll a grapple check. Goddamnit.
Lmao
I would love to see an analysis of all the rolls in that game… It would make a great youtube video.
I liked the whole movie, but honestly my favorite part was the reveal at the beginning for why they were waiting for that one judge.
The chase scene where the druid constantly wildshaped was amazing. Also Themberchaud.
It was! The music really made that part excellent.
Themberchaud was the fat dragon right? That was a very homebrew dnd moment… The movie was good at that.
That’s right. He shows up in Out of the Abyss.
I liked the small cameos in the maze battle scene. The characters from the 1980’s cartoon show made an appearance, even if they didn’t say anything.
Ha! I never saw that cartoon, but it did seem like they put some thought into those characters. I may have to look them up.
Hahahaha oh man that’s stupid and I love it. I want to watch some of that cartoon now.
It was a constant part of my Saturday mornings. It was stupid, but there was just enough lore to keep us all waiting for the next episode.
There’s so many great scenes, like the Intellect Devourers completely ignore the party, and the fact that all of their classes use intelligence as a dump stat. Or how fantastically shot that entire escape from the tower sequence was. Or how clever the intentionally jumping into the gelatonus cube was…
But my absolute favorite scene was when the paladin was walking away and Edgin said oh no there’s a rock in his way, will he go around? And he walks straight up and over it. It had us dying, we had to pause it because we laughing so hard.
“But we approved your pardon!”
Simple, hilarious, and sounds like the DM response rather than the character.
The use of the “hither tither” stick, it felt exactly how a player would use it
Also exactly how it would be introduced. Intricate puzzle the DM spent hours designing, fucking it up instantly, then just being like oh shit, lucky we had this staff the DM made during his portal playthrough
Aside from the how well the humor landed I thought that the fight scenes were really well choreographed. Not this mention how every character follows the initiative order in the final fight scene. Pretty nifty. Overall it was a great movie.
A lot to be said, but I think my favorite little thing was the rust monsters eating scrap for the 1.5 seconds they were on screen. Entirely unnecessary, but showed they put in a good amount of thought to the film.
Probably the bridge. DM crafted such an amazing puzzle and the paladin being a good boy learned it perfectly. Group was like: You know it’d be fun to see what the DM does if I accidentally put my foot on it.
Also the five questions. You could see that coming from MILES away but it was still hilarious.
The bridge scene is even better when you realize the paladin is a DM-insert NPC, there to explain the overcomplicated puzzles, steer the plot, and keep the incompetent party from getting killed. Once they’re back on track with what the DM has prepped, he says his farewell and disappears from the story.
BUT WE APPROVED YOUR PARDON
It’s been a minute since I saw it but I thought the humor was well executed. There’s a lot of talk lately about how modern blockbusters (read: marvel) are oversaturated with humor, but I feel like Honor Among Thieves struck just the right balance for a movie about DnD.
Edot: will say that my friend still cracks up whenever he thinks of Themberchaud so that’s probably where his vote goes
JARNATHAN! Probably because it was both funny and kind of meta to me. It just really seems like a name a player would improv on the spot after the DM asks for more backstop info, haha. Jonathan? No, to normal…Jarnathan tho… that has potential.
So many parts
The failing illusion check when trying to sneak into the castle
“Jarnathan!”
The dude walking a straight line right over the rock.
And the fact that they made a D&D movie that was all around fantastic. Like whatever that uwe boll movie that happened earlier has now been rectified.
